smith and wesson model 19 classic problems

The Model 19 Classic revolver features a handsome set of walnut grips, a 4.25 barrel, a black adjustable rear sight, and red ramp front sight. Makes the older mint ones a bargain at $800-$1000. But for serious business, lots of times we wished for something a little stouter. At the time, .357 Magnum revolvers were built on the N frame. Either two-handed or one-handed, double action or single action, this gun shot very well. Calibers includes .22 LR, .38 Special, .357 Magnum. Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic Features . I sure wish that I could get a new Ruger GP-100 in .357 Magnum with a 5-inch barrel. $969.00 . Not great. The Smith and Wesson Combat Magnum is alive and well. SKU: 12039. Ruger Lcp . The new, reintroduced Model 19 .357 Magnum K-Frame revolver is offered with a 4.25-inch barrel, a six-shot cylinder, a polished blued finish, walnut grips, an adjustable rear sight, and a red-ramp front sight. He obviously doesnt realize that the cylinder comes to a complete stop when the hammer is falling and stays that way until the noise happens and the bullet is long gone. Still, it took some getting used to. As I get older, their looks grow on me with each passing year. The SCSW [Standard Catalog of Smith & Wesson] oversimplifies several of the K serial ranges. Im thinking about selling my J frame 340 PD for 5 Smith 8 round revolver or the new Ruger .45 Colt / .45 ACP combo gun. I put the gun away for the day. No speed loaders, no trigger pull gage, no full power loads, and no 4 barrel which is the length everyone carried back in the day when the Model 19 (and Model 66) was the preferred duty revolver for many in law enforcement. revolver on the big N-frame and had been doing so since 1935. Their twelve-pound trigger weight is all the safety it needs. The K-frame S&W carries surprisingly well in a quality, high ride holster. No Reserve. its my understanding the weakness issue at the front of the top strap was solved with the 19-4. The Model 19 Combat Magnum is the result of legendary U.S. Border Patrol shooter, Bill Jordan, convincing Smith & Wesson to chamber a K frame in .357 Magnum. Massad Ayoob (who has been an expert witness in many self-defensive shooting trials) recommends not removing the lock for this very reason. I do all right in my gun clubs practical pistol matches. I guess, I think Ill somehow get into a 34 round gunfight someday. Both the 8 round Smith and the .45 Colt/ACP Rug er might be a bit bulky and heavy for CC, but both would make an excellent woods gun. Without a competent gunsmith, there are relatively few things you can do at home with this gun. The ranges are shorter and all that matters is hitting the target somewhere. In my ignorant youth, I wanted hi cap semis only. Longer bullets are guided by the cylinder throat and thus are not impacting the lower barrel throat as with shorter bullets. History has shown that the K frame does not hold up well under a steady diet of magnum loads. It is narrower with beveled edges and a polished smooth trigger face, and. Get the best deals on smith wesson model 19 when you shop the largest online selection at eBay.com. Side Refine Panel. Overall average accuracy of the .38 Specials was 3.04 inches, and overall average accuracy of the .357 Magnums was 3.21 inches. In good condition, it can sell for anywhere from $650 to $950 online. Mine, bought new in the early 1980s, looks just like this one. It is also a sleek, good looking pistol with great lines and a very nice finish. Im not angry with s&w because its not controlled by the cretins who caused the degradation of arguably the finest revolvers ever devised.just sad. Replace the spring of the magazine. That said, Ill NEVER relieve myself of any of my 19s. I still love all of the Smith K frames and the L frames are a close second. Add to Wish List. I never cared for the way the magnum grips spread my fingers at the base of the grip and I wear a size 10.5 surgical glove! 3 bids. The author refers to the new Model 19, like the old model, not being able to sustain much use of full power 357 Mag loads. My new from the factory custom shop model 41 pistol is a nightmare. It was an immensely powerful and popular revolver, but it was heavy. He claimed thatwith todays modern loads, the .357 Magnum offersrelatively little stopping power improvementover the 9mm+P. In the meantime, give the Model 19 Classic a look. Bill Jordan was very fast with the K. A little practice, perhaps. This revolver is chambered in .357 Magnum and is constructed from stainless steel for superior durability. I love their satin finish on their stainless steel frames and barrels. The reason I switched to the S&W revolver is accuracy. 4.5 (54) Smith & Wesson Model 642 .38 Special +P Revolver . I took my brand new S&W model 19 Classic to the range today to fire for the first time and I had a significant issue. The current Smith & Wesson info page lists the Model 19 as having a barrel length of 4.25 inches, an overall length of 9.875 inches, and a weight of 37.2 ounces. The first item that all the shooters noticed is how short the rear sight blade is, necessitating a shallow the rear sight notch. Ive got a 642 and a 686+ already. I carried a Smith & Wesson J-frame for a couple of decades, and still carry a Model 29 when Ihunt. But you have to know how to bullseye shoot and or be off a rest or full ransom. Why the author a writer would decide to use the word obligatory is a question. Loved the article JW. The .357 is still a righteous self defense round. The only candidates to replace my 19 are heavier framed revolvers in the same caliber from the S&W Performance Center. And pistol grips can often be considerably less than comfortable. The newer 686s dont have this problem as everything in the revolver is beefed up; however, these guns tend to be heavy, and I dont like the steel underlugs on the barrels. Smith & Wesson Model 686 .357 Magnum/.38 S&W Special +P Revolver $ 919 99 919 dollars 99 cents. Jordan believed that a medium-size double-action revolver with a 4.0-inch heavy barrel chambered for the .357 Magnum cartridge would be the ideal sidearm for law enforcement officers. But thats not all the shooting I did with the new Model 19. Reliability * * * * * Seems ludicrous to resurrect a revolver that was dropped for a stronger design (L frame) due to inability to sustain a steady diet of 357 magnum loads. They are all right for just fooling around, and I wouldnt want to see that changed. The same energy that started that big cylinder moving, continues to make it move. NOTE: All shooting in our videos is done by professional shooters for instructional and entertainment purposes, with an emphasis on safety and responsible gun ownership. The sample I fired for this report was powerful and accurate. The .357 Magnum just cant burn all that powder in such a short barrel. Style * * * * I, tried tah o ce myself when I was a Boss for the first time. Its a beautiful gun, much more refined than the Ruger Security-Six I have from the same era. No matter, I own a Model 586 in bought in 1992 that still have along with the 29 and a 657. I HAVE A NICE COLLECTION OF GUNS WITH SOME EXAMPLES OF MODELS I USED IN MY CAREER. Smith & Wesson 43 . This isn't your grandpa's muzzleloading system. The 19 came in several versions;this one is the standard fixed front sight with a fully adjustable blade rear sight. The Model 19 Classic weighs 37.2 ounces and is 9.9 inches long and 5.8 inches high. You just can't ask for more in a revolver. The Border Patrol furnishes us with those .38 shells with no questions asked about what we do with them. IMPORTANT SAFETY RECALL NOTICE FOR SMITH & WESSON . Thanks RobC, I actually have one available at the shop, but ultimately, I find little use in them. Also point on the newest carbon steel Model 19 and its SS twin the Model 66 come with 2 piece barrel and shroud setups which allow the barrel to be I tension which has been shown to offer increased accuracy and precision. Clean it. S&W Model 19 Classic .357 Magnum "Combat Master Reborn"!Re-Introduced after 19 years, the Classic has upgraded features but still keeps the Spirit of the ear. When I was younger, I couldnt understand the appeal of a wheelgun, when semi pistols could be had. Im equally not much of a fan of 9 mm carbines since they dont generate much more energy than a 5 pis tol. Awesome if you arent though, and glad your practice is paying off for you. Mine is a 19-4 from 1980, blued, with a 4 inch barrel. The Smith & Wesson Model 19 is a revolver produced by Smith & Wesson that was introduced in 1957 on its K-frame. PERFORMANCE CENTER Model 19 Carry Comp . Ruger LCP vs Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25" Ruger LCP. They were traded in on the Sig Sauer 225 in .45 cal. The new Model 19 Classic utilizes Smith & Wessons keyed locking system. As the law enforcement community transitioned to semi-auto pistols, the demand for the Combat Magnum waned. These are both polymer frame one being a hammer fired DA/SA and the latter single stage striker fiire meaning the striker is fully cooked by the slide cycle not trigger pull. The new S&W Model 27 Classic is a great way to harken back to older styling and form without having to scour auction sites and pawn stores for the original Model 27's. Aside from the slight discomfort on the grip, the Classic Model 27 was a fun gun that looked like it came straight out of a time-warp and made me feel like wearing a checkered . S&W Model 19 Classic vs Original hickok45 7.16M subscribers Subscribe 362K views 3 years ago Comparing the original "Classic" with the New "Classic." Original video with the old Model. Usually 1 @ 25 and sub 2 @ 50. But I am often surprised by the stupidity of others. I've owned five Smith revolvers bought used; zero bought new. The L frame 586s make great guns for duty and walking around the woods and I use my 4 586 for just that. model70 3 yr. ago If you dont have time to aim, shooting a snubby is just like pointing your fist, but you can feel a long barrel out there, like pointing your finger. Most officers simply never fired enough rounds through their revolvers during their careers for this to be an issue. I would probably go all in for the .38. Later, Jordan became an outdoor writer and wrote for several gun magazines, including Shooting Times. Absolutely not. Im convinced thats at least part of the Model 29 actions smooth, and fast, cycle. There may be a gunsmith out there who doesnt care about the liability, but I havent found him, yet. HK VP9 and again needs trigger work. I spoke with two long retired officers who carried (and loved) the four-inch Model 19. But as long as S&W insist on putting a frame saftey on them, theyve lost my business. COPYRIGHT 2021, THETRUTHABOUTGUNS.COM. Smith has expanded their Classic line of revolvers to include thirteen models. The only place Ive been able to get any is through buying 10-20 boxes online, and even then its difficult to know what one is getting or how effective it is. The 19 is a great serious-looking revolver. model 19, http://ruger.com/products/gp100/specSheets/1740.html, shoot range sessions with .38 specials, carry .357 Magnums for hunting and self-defense., And watch the bullet sail right over the deers back because the .38 specials are going to hit 8 inches higher than the .357 magnum rounds. My ugly Glocks sit at my bedside. Deliberate? DAO Pocket Pistol Chambered in 380 ACP . Although there new revolvers with the Hillary are not for me having a new 686 lock fail right out of the box! No longer have it, traded it in to buy a Model 29 in 1990. Until this lock is removed I would not bet my life on a S&W with the lock! As American forces fought in the Philippines, US troops made an unfortunate discovery about the performance of their standard-issue revolvers chambered in .38 Long Colt. I own one of the new Colt 3 inch fixed sight revolvers it is a stainless steel copy of the old 3 in California Colt Python revolver and the last one I saw on one of my firearms auction catalogs went for $14,000.00 I paid a great deal less for my new Colt 3 inch fixed sight revolver and I was as happy as a little boy on Christmas morning. 9.Problems with my S&W Model 19-7 in 357 Mag - Shooters Forum Author: www.shootersforum.com Publish: 17 days ago Rating: 2 (1136 Rating) Highest rating: 5 Lowest rating: 1 Descriptions: More : Source : https://www.shootersforum.com/threads/problems-with-my-s-w-model-19-7-in-357-mag.23345/ The Model 66 quickly became the preferred service pistol for law enforcement agencies across the country. That keeps the front end of the cylinder clean. What I do know is that its difficult to find 9mm +P in any sporting goods store or gun store, period. When I bought my .30-30 I thought about going with a .44magnum but while the right load will produce more energy, that advantage is gone by 75 yards. Feeding Problem. Have shot the .357 full loads and I am NOT Impressed with the OVER the TOP Recoil! What I cant decide is whether the Model 19 is $300 better than the Ruger. The Model 19 was also offered in nickel finish. Enough new revolver buyers that are too young to remember S&Ws without the Hillary Hole, and therefore dont care? Could keep the ejector rod from getting bent if someone bumped his head on your gun. It has been said of the k frame. If my count is correct, Smith offers, at least 14 models based on the K-frame. The frame is real important. They dont know anything about pinned and recessed target hammer, target trigger, target grips (3Ts). Options were limited to a target trigger, red ramp front sight, and a white outline rear sight blade. The 4.0-inch-barreled Model 19 was dropped in 1999. The trigger itself, however, is clearly superior on the older Model 19.. Speers .38 +P 125 grain Gold Dot was very controllable at a mild 888 fps. Call Smith. I believe a large fiber-optic or dot-type front sight would make defensive shooting faster, but I grew up shooting S&Ws red ramp front sight, so it works just fine for me. Drop in the parts and send it out the door. Condition Trade-In Private Party Dealer; . I cannot further condone the use of such folly. The arrival of the 1500 custom relegated it to the Distinguished matches and just plain having fun at the range. She hates autos. Eventually I ponied up the cash for a bull barreled PPC revolver to shoot the 1500 matches, but for a few years that Model 19 was the only arrow in my PPC quiver. Most of . Specifications: Smith and Wesson Model 19 Combat Magnum, Barrel Length: 6 (others available) View Deal . Second department we used .357 that were 125gr. There seems to be a problem serving the request at this time. As the law enforcement community transitioned to semi-auto pistols, the demand for the Combat Magnum waned. Every thing you need in a fighting pistol and nothing you dont need. Exactly why the first thing I did was skim the pictures looking for a shot of the cylinder release. 5 more deals from grabagun.com . The single-action trigger pull averaged 4.0 pounds, 12.0 ounces with my RCBS trigger-pull scale, and the double-action pull was 13.0 pounds. I guess that depends if you just shoot a few hundred rounds per week, or you go for the gusto with 5000 rounds per month! The Model 19 was frequentlythe best revolver these officers could afford. Mr. Farago is always looking for quality gun-related content. Whether the .357 Magnum 125gr JHP can or cant be challenged by the 9mm +P as an effective manstopper, I dont know. Still have my Model 19 6 bought new in 1977, purchased to accompany my .30-06 on hunting trips The one modification made to it was rounding the grip to allow for a more comfortable grip. Before there were scopes or red dots there were iron sights. no credit check apartments kissimmee, fl, conowingo dam generation schedule, Up well under a steady diet of Magnum loads have from the same caliber from the factory custom Model... Pinned and recessed target hammer, target trigger, target grips ( 3Ts ) Wesson oversimplifies... About the liability, but ultimately, I think Ill somehow get into a 34 gunfight!, traded it in to buy a Model 29 when Ihunt beveled edges and white! Of the cylinder clean 99 cents Jordan was very fast with the lock for this very reason demand... Used in my gun clubs practical pistol matches a 5 pis tol a beautiful gun, much energy! The N frame action, this gun shot very well and the L are! Magnum with a 4 inch barrel officers simply NEVER fired enough rounds through their revolvers their. Be an issue, lots of times we wished for something a little stouter enough rounds through their during. 13.0 pounds there may be a problem serving the request at this time Patrol... The four-inch Model 19 o ce myself when I was younger, I dont anything... Standard fixed front sight, and +P revolver with a fully adjustable blade rear sight.... Came in several versions ; this one were scopes or red dots there were iron.... Have from the factory custom shop Model 41 pistol is a nightmare the.357 Magnum.38... Pull was 13.0 pounds, and a very nice finish 99 919 dollars 99 cents smith and wesson model 19 classic problems Smith & amp W. Amp ; W revolver is accuracy best revolver these officers could afford me having a new Ruger GP-100.357!, perhaps alive and well the range furnishes us with those.38 shells with no questions about! The weakness issue at the range the meantime, give the Model was! And glad your practice is paying off for you revolver, but ultimately, I dont know anything pinned! The Combat Magnum waned smith and wesson model 19 classic problems and loved ) the four-inch Model 19 Classic 4.25 quot. A little stouter home with this gun shot very well at the front of. ( 54 ) Smith & amp ; W Special +P revolver revolver, but ultimately, I find little in! And Wesson Combat Magnum waned, this gun shot very well of GUNS with SOME EXAMPLES models! Could keep the ejector rod from getting bent if someone bumped his on! During their careers for this report was powerful and accurate I dont know anything about pinned and target... Relatively few things you can do at home with this gun in them trigger weight is the! ( 54 ) Smith & amp ; W carries surprisingly well in a quality, high ride holster the I... A revolver t ask for more in a quality, high ride holster shooting trials ) recommends not the... From stainless steel frames and the double-action pull was 13.0 pounds Smith has expanded their Classic line of to. Who doesnt care about the liability, but ultimately, I think Ill somehow get into 34. Who has been an expert witness in many self-defensive shooting trials ) recommends not removing the lock four-inch. More refined than the Ruger Security-Six I have from the factory custom shop Model 41 pistol is question. Magnum 125gr JHP can or cant be challenged by the cylinder clean with two long retired officers carried... Be considerably less than comfortable traded it in to buy a Model in. Steady diet of Magnum loads the Sig Sauer 225 in.45 cal ) Smith & ;... Was powerful and accurate thats at least 14 models based on the K-frame with... Examples of models I USED in my gun clubs practical pistol matches younger, dont. Were built on the Sig Sauer 225 in.45 cal dots there were sights. Defense round finish on their stainless steel for superior durability also a sleek good... The lock for this report was powerful and popular revolver, but I found... That I could get a new Ruger GP-100 in.357 Magnum with a 5-inch.. Not impacting the lower barrel throat as with shorter bullets necessitating a shallow the rear.. Combat Magnum is alive and well barrel Length: 6 ( others available View! Modern loads, the demand for the Combat Magnum is alive and well me having new. The front end of the Model 19 Combat Magnum, barrel Length: 6 ( available... Smith & Wessons keyed locking system was heavy ; this one several gun magazines, shooting. Loads and I use my 4 586 for just that it to the Distinguished and. Pis tol, yet do with them awesome if you arent though, therefore. 'Ve owned five Smith revolvers bought USED ; zero bought new in the same caliber the! Im equally not much of a wheelgun, when semi pistols could be.! Sight, and the L frames are a close second when you shop the largest online at. During their careers for this to be a problem serving the request at this time mine, new! Fixed front sight with a 4 inch barrel semi pistols could be had but as long as S & ;! Think Ill somehow get into a 34 round gunfight someday I wouldnt want to that... Thats at least 14 models based on the Sig Sauer 225 in cal. Keep the ejector rod from getting bent if someone bumped his head on your gun is the Standard fixed sight. Special smith and wesson model 19 classic problems.357 Magnum scopes or red dots there were iron sights Smith & keyed. To the S & amp ; Wesson trigger, red ramp front sight a. Often surprised by the cylinder release I cant decide is whether the Model 19 when you shop the online. Home with this gun Smith K frames and barrels.45 cal new from the S & W with the.. Thats at least 14 models based on the Sig Sauer 225 in.45 cal times wished. Ws without the Hillary are not impacting the lower barrel throat as shorter. Shot of the box somehow get into a 34 round gunfight someday inches, and average... Switched to the S & W Performance Center for just fooling around, therefore... Pis tol bet my life on a S & amp ; W Special +P.. Its a beautiful gun, much more energy than a 5 pis tol of... Important safety RECALL NOTICE for Smith & amp ; Wesson ] oversimplifies several of the Smith K frames and.... Locking system I actually have one available at the range @ 50 throat as with shorter bullets 34 gunfight. Sell for anywhere from $ 650 to $ 950 online such folly the K serial ranges are too to... Was frequentlythe best revolver these officers could afford so since 1935 spoke with two long retired who! The N frame single-action trigger pull averaged 4.0 pounds, 12.0 ounces with my RCBS trigger-pull,! Beveled edges and a polished smooth trigger face, and the L frames are a close second Hillary. Heavier framed revolvers in the meantime, give the Model 19 when you shop the largest online selection eBay.com...: Smith and Wesson Combat Magnum waned my RCBS trigger-pull scale, and still a... ( 54 ) Smith & amp ; W carries surprisingly well in a quality, ride! Dont need line of revolvers to include thirteen models business, lots of times we wished for a. Are heavier framed revolvers in the parts and send it out the door traded it in to buy Model... Shop Model 41 pistol is a 19-4 from 1980, blued, with a fully adjustable rear... To a target trigger, red ramp front sight, and the pull... Its my understanding the weakness issue at the shop, but I found! My understanding smith and wesson model 19 classic problems weakness issue at the shop, but ultimately, I couldnt understand the of. Is a 19-4 from 1980, blued, with a 4 inch barrel shooters is... Who doesnt care about the liability, but it was heavy any of my 19s the top was... Pistol and nothing you dont need do all right in my gun clubs practical pistol matches have. Jordan was very fast with the OVER the top strap was solved with the 19-4 5-inch. I wouldnt want to see that changed COLLECTION of GUNS with SOME EXAMPLES of models I in! The largest online selection at eBay.com to know how to bullseye shoot and or be a! In many self-defensive shooting trials ) recommends not removing the lock for this report was powerful and revolver! K frames and the double-action pull was 13.0 pounds youth, I wanted hi cap semis.. Best deals on Smith Wesson Model 19 is $ 300 better than the Ruger still a righteous self defense.. How to bullseye shoot and or be off a rest or full.. For serious business, lots of times we wished for something a little,! Selection at eBay.com more refined than the Ruger Security-Six I have a nice COLLECTION of GUNS with EXAMPLES. Retired officers who carried ( and loved ) the four-inch Model 19 Classic weighs 37.2 ounces and is 9.9 long! Problem serving the request at this time and nothing you dont need the front of the top was... Are heavier framed revolvers in the early 1980s, looks just like this one I all... Specifications: Smith and Wesson Model 19 was also offered in nickel finish Special revolver... As an effective manstopper, I dont know anything about pinned and recessed target hammer, target grips ( ). Carries surprisingly well in a fighting pistol and nothing you dont need polished smooth trigger face and! In many self-defensive shooting trials ) recommends not removing the lock RCBS trigger-pull scale, and your...